How to deal with production or release dates in extinct countries? I see no way to add them to the list, so it seams to be impossible to enter different release dates for east and west germany or to decide whether consider a czechoslovak movie as czech or slovak one
فیلم و نمایش تلویزیونی را نمیتوانید پیدا کنید؟ به سیستم وارد شوید تا آن را ایجاد کنید.
آیا میخواهید به این مورد امتیاز دهید یا به فهرست اضافه کنید؟
عضو نیستید؟
پاسخ توسط Travis Bell
در تاریخ نوامبر 22, 2013 ساعت 11:47 ق.ض
If you have a list of missing countries, let me know and I'll see about getting them added. So far, I have:
Let me know if you see some others.
پاسخ توسط Karl Dietz
در تاریخ نوامبر 23, 2013 ساعت 4:49 ب.ض
I'm not sure into how much detail you want to go, as movie have been created for some time now. e.g. http://www.themoviedb.org/person/29110-carl-froelich (first hit for the relevant time from http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liste_der_Regisseure_des_deutschen_Films)
If someone feels like going through a list... good luck ;) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_former_sovereign_states
پاسخ توسط senax
در تاریخ نوامبر 23, 2013 ساعت 5:32 ب.ض
You could use https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_3166-1 just like Musicbrainz does. -> https://musicbrainz.org/doc/Release_Country lists some historical countries.
پاسخ توسط Travis Bell
در تاریخ نوامبر 23, 2013 ساعت 6:03 ب.ض
We do use ISO 3166-1. If you look at the list West Germany and the countries we're discussing here are not on it as independent countries. That's the issue here. They're not part of the current standard and are currently lumped into their current country ie. Germany, or even worse, in Czechoslovakia's case, they re-assigned the CS value to Serbia and Montenegro.
پاسخ توسط TikiWho
در تاریخ مه 11, 2014 ساعت 3:33 ق.ض
If you could add the Soviet Union, that would be great. Soviet Cinema is so strikingly different from modern Russian cinema.
پاسخ توسط Travis Bell
در تاریخ دسامبر 1, 2014 ساعت 6:22 ب.ض
Another one to consider is Kosovo. It's marked under the "User-assigned" group on the Wikipedia list.
پاسخ توسط Faruz
در تاریخ ژانویه 28, 2015 ساعت 3:41 ب.ض
Any chance of this is changing any time soon? Feels like adding a bunch of countries should be a relatively quick fix, no?
پاسخ توسط Theli93
در تاریخ اکتبر 5, 2015 ساعت 8:07 ق.ض
This appears to still not have been addressed. From 1949 to 1990 East Germany and West Germany were separate nations (or as Karl Dietz noted above GDR and FRG). That's excess of 40 years of unresolvable errors and inaccuracies for prime and classic films!
پاسخ توسط Samara
در تاریخ اکتبر 5, 2015 ساعت 9:36 ق.ض
I think we should not seperate West and East Germany now because Germany got all the rights of the movies and other stuff after the reunion. So I think there should be Germany only
پاسخ توسط TikiWho
در تاریخ اکتبر 5, 2015 ساعت 9:39 ق.ض
Germany may have gotten the rights, but a film made in East Germany is very different from a film made in West Germany, thus I believe there is value to adding that distinction of origin.
پاسخ توسط Samara
در تاریخ اکتبر 5, 2015 ساعت 1:07 ب.ض
But it's not a different country I'm german and I see no reason to have two germanys here, a movie from Bavaria is different to a movie in Hamburg but it's the same country, even the actors are the same
پاسخ توسط TikiWho
در تاریخ اکتبر 5, 2015 ساعت 1:29 ب.ض
I'd be all for regional distinctions as well. I'd love to be able to indicate that a film in the US wasn't made in Hollywood, for example, and Indian cinema varies widely based on region. It's not all Bollywood.
پاسخ توسط Samara
در تاریخ اکتبر 5, 2015 ساعت 7:24 ب.ض
Yes but I really think that could be done with a keyword instead, the other way would be too much for a database, just my opinion
پاسخ توسط Theli93
در تاریخ اکتبر 8, 2015 ساعت 2:18 ب.ض
My point here is in dealing with release dates, the area on a map is not the same as a country; territory is not government. What is permitted in one territory may well not be in another. Release dates in communist nations and democratic nations my vary by decades, in both directions, yet this is a time-frame in which many of the classic films fall! This is precisely the issue when dealing with East and West Germany. There is also the issue of accuracy; I am very disappointed that IMDb can provide a level of accuracy in which we continue to fail.
پاسخ توسط Samara
در تاریخ اکتبر 8, 2015 ساعت 2:23 ب.ض
IMDB is more accurate? I can't see movies from Ohio, Missouri for example, only from the United States of America, no Scotland or Wales only United Kingdom, so I think IMDB is not a perfect example