Beyoncé, hands down. Harry Styles as well.

That's the two I know of. I'm not into latin music, so I'm not anticipating Xtina's release at all.

@mrjacs said:

Beyoncé, hands down. Harry Styles as well.

That's the two I know of. I'm not into latin music, so I'm not anticipating Xtina's release at all.

Wow …… here you go again treating queen like trash. I bet if Lady Hagga released a Latin album you would cheer about how ahead of her time she is and it’s breaking records.

You should feel a shame of yourself. Just admit you only like Christina when she was slaying the charts that’s it.

@Rulee said:

Wow …… here you go again treating queen like trash. I bet if Lady Hagga released a Latin album you would cheer about how ahead of her time she is and it’s breaking records.

You should feel a shame of yourself. Just admit you only like Christina when she was slaying the charts that’s it.

I don't support Lady Gaga's jazz albums either.

Besides, didn't you excuse Xtina's La Fuerza selling like it did because it doesn't appeal to a mass audience? You stated that in an earlier post

So by your logic, just because you're an Xtina stan you should support everything she does? Well, does that mean Xtina doesn't have enough stans to even enter the Billboard 200 with La Fuerza then? Because if every single stan of her would've supported La Fuerza it surely would've sold better?

Please explain

So by your logic, just because you're an Xtina stan you should support everything she does? Well, does that mean Xtina doesn't have enough stans to even enter the Billboard 200 with La Fuerza then? Because if every single stan of her would've supported La Fuerza it surely would've sold better?

Please explain

It’s 2022 & it had no physical. Literally nobody would chart well without it.

Also just because that’s what i believe in doesn’t mean anyone outside of myself will follow that you sure won’t.

You will shade her next EP like you did this one because you’re a success queen.

Remember when you turn into Casper when Beyonce last project bombed Joanna style.

@Rulee said:

It’s 2022 & it had no physical. Literally nobody would chart well without it.

Singles have no physicals and yet they chart. There are albums charting based on one song as well, so it's not a very good excuse

Please explain why none of the singles charted then?

You've really dragged yourself into a corner with this one.

Remember when you turn into Casper when Beyonce last project bombed Joanna style.

Joanne sold over 2 million, Beyoncé's album was nowhere near that successful. That album generated sales of 880,000+ units which is around the same as Christina Aguilera's last full-length studio album did. Why did you not use that as an example?

Joanne literally sold more than Christina's and Beyoncé's album combined lol. And by more I mean even when you add Xtina's and Bey's albums up you get 1.6 million units which is still less than Joanne. You need better examples boo

Please explain why none of the singles charted then?

The two singles PMM & Santos did chart on the Latin billboard charts which is where it’s target was. In fact both singles did well PMM went gold Santo is next.

There are albums charting based on one song as well, so it's not a very good excuse

I’m unsure why you can’t comprehend that she released a EP. Maluma released a EP that did worst than Xtina’s yet he’s more known in the current Latin world. Same with Becky G & Rosalía EPs that didn’t chart.

Christina’s full Spanish album release will chart. I’m not expecting a EP to make any noise especially with Christina being gone from the market for 20 years along with being 40.

Joanne literally sold more than Christina's and Beyoncé's album combined

Thanks to the super bowl. The album along with its singles were bombing hard originally for Gaga standards. I’m almost positive if Christina did the super bowl during liberation it would’ve done the same.

Sky Ferreira and Carly Rae Jepsen

@High King said:

Sky Ferreira and Carly Rae Jepsen

Do we know when miss Rae is dropping that lead single? I’m interested.

Sky Ferreira and Carly Rae Jepsen

So Sky is definately releasing this year?

@Rulee said:

Christina’s full Spanish album release will chart. I’m not expecting a EP to make any noise especially with Christina being gone from the market for 20 years along with being 40.

So you expect it to chart as well as her regular studio albums? And sell as much as well? Because that's what you're implying

Thanks to the super bowl. The album along with its singles were bombing hard originally for Gaga standards. I’m almost positive if Christina did the super bowl during liberation it would’ve done the same.

Actually, Joanne had sold 1 million before the Super Bowl and that's already more than Xtina's and Beyoncé's albums. We're talking facts here, you were wrong No need to be mad though, it happens sometimes. But there hasn't been a single moment since Gaga debuted where Xtina would've been more popular, regardless if she did the Super Bowl or not. The Super Bowl didn't catapult J.Lo back into selling like Gaga, did it? Neither did Shakira suddenly do Joanne numbers in the US.

Xtina's last album tanked and so did Beyoncé's recent soundtrack album. Both of them combined aren't close to the sales of Joanne either, both before the Super Bowl and after. This isn't shade though, it's just facts.

So you expect it to chart as well as her regular studio albums? And sell as much as well? Because that's what you're implying

I’m implying that her Spanish album will chart. That’s it. That was our original topic.

The Super Bowl didn't catapult J.Lo back into selling like Gaga, did it? Neither did Shakira suddenly do Joanne numbers in the US.

Neither of them released a full solo album after their super bowl performance so we have no clue what the sales would be. It’s unfortunate they didn’t release close to the super bowl like Gaga did now it’s simply too late. It’s pretty obvious Gaga was going to underperform before the super bowl though.

Xtina's last album tanked

Simply not true it sold 77K first week which is decent for her seeing she’s 20 years into her career. The album was met with rave reviews and acclaimed. It’s also a Grammy nominated album. Its no smash but i think it did well for her.

@Rulee said:

I’m implying that her Spanish album will chart. That’s it. That was our original topic.

The original topic was actually you attacking me for not supporting Xtina's latin music when I'm clearly not the only one. Didn't her first latin album sell like 40k in its first week, while Stripped did 200k+? Mi Reflejo debuted outside of the top 20 during her peak, yet Stripped debuted at No. 2. Explain that.

Neither of them released a full solo album after their super bowl performance so we have no clue what the sales would be. It’s unfortunate they didn’t release close to the super bowl like Gaga did now it’s simply too late. It’s pretty obvious Gaga was going to underperform before the super bowl though.

Shakira released her single "Me Gusta" just weeks before her Super Bowl performance, even going as far as making pop-up stores for the single:

"To celebrate Shakira's upcoming Super Bowl Halftime Show performance, a special "Me Gusta"-themed pop-up store was put up in Miami. It featured colored walls and fancy furniture that resembled the song's music video setting. In the store on January 31 and February 1, among several items, fans could purchase an exclusive "Me Gusta" clothing line, that was later added on Shakira's official online store. On March 11, 2020, a "Me Gusta" official Instagram filter was sponsored by Shakira."

But this isn't even about that. Gaga's post-Super Bowl sales were way bigger and we've seen artists like Justin Timberlake perform brand new singles and none of them enjoyed the same sales surge as Gaga's Million Reasons or Joanne.

Simply not true it sold 77K first week which is decent for her seeing she’s 20 years into her career. The album was met with rave reviews and acclaimed. It’s also a Grammy nominated album. Its no smash but i think it did well for her.

But then there was Lotus as well which is considered a flop. This isn't even about Xtina, this is about you calling Joanne a bomb when it wasn't as it did what Lotus and Beyoncé's soundtrack albums did combined and what Xtina's album did to date in just five-six week without the Super Bowl. It clearly wasn't a bomb by any means so please refrain from calling it one and we're good

."

Shakira released her single "Me Gusta" just weeks before her Super Bowl performance, even going as far as making pop-up stores for the single:

The single was certified x2 Platinum in Spain, Platinum+Gold in Mexico and Gold in Italy. It moved to number 6th on the Latin charts. The super bowl clearly helped. That’s success to me!

Gaga's post-Super Bowl sales were way bigger and we've seen artists like Justin Timberlake perform brand new singles and none of them enjoyed the same sales surge as Gaga's Million Reasons or Joanne.

So you admit the super bowl did help Gaga tragic singles. 🤡. Just because it helped Gaga the most doesn’t mean it didn’t help the others.

Joanne a bomb when it wasn't as it did what Lotus and Beyoncé's soundtrack albums did combined.

Xtina & Beyonce are NOT Gaga peers. Both debut a whole decade before her. It’s strange that you keep comparing them to Gaga. Let’s compare to Gaga actual peers Rihanna, Taylor & Katy who destroy her in sales around that time.

Joanne WAS a Under performance on the verge of flopping UNTIL like you said the super bowl giving her the BIGGEST surge. Your words!! The lead single completely bomb & Million reasons was heading in the same direction.

Didn't her first latin album sell like 40k in its first week, while Stripped did 200k+? Mi Reflejo debuted outside of the top 20 during her peak, yet Stripped debuted at No. 2. Explain that.

Are you implying that her debut Spanish album wasn’t successful?

@Rulee said:

Xtina & Beyonce are NOT Gaga peers. Both debut a whole decade before her.

But... you were the one comparing Beyoncé's soundtrack to Joanne. In your original post you compared those two. And you've been comparing Beyoncé and Xtina in discussions about Gaga, Rihanna or Katy for years, so what's that sudden change in narrative?

You compared Beyonce's The Lion King soundtrack which bombed to Gaga's Joanne even though they aren't even in the same ball park of sales. You started comparing them in the first place, so please stay on one path.

Joanne WAS a Under performance on the verge of flopping UNTIL like you said the super bowl giving her the BIGGEST surge. Your words!! The lead single completely bomb & Million reasons was heading in the same direction.

But you called Joanne a bomb. There's a difference between a bomb (Britney Jean) and an underperformance (Joanne). You compared the sales of an album that sold 880k in three years to an album that sold 1 million in five weeks (without the Super Bowl) and I simply stated how utterly incomparable it was.

Are you implying that her debut Spanish album wasn’t successful?

No. I'm saying that clearly MORE FANS are supporting her regular studio albums than her side-projects which is why they don't do as well commercially, so you attacking me for not supporting one of her side-projects and therefore implying I'm not a fan because of that is stupid and unfair. Not every fan is willing to buy an album that's a remix or latin or what have you. Which is why those albums don't sell like regular studio albums.

You should just apologize for your mistake and let's move on.

You compared Beyonce's The Lion King soundtrack which bombed to Gaga's Joanne even though they aren't even in the same ball park of sales.

I was wrong . I simply meant Beyonce flopped & you disappeared..

But you called Joanne a bomb. There's a difference between a bomb (Britney Jean) and an underperformance (Joanne)

You’re right it was the singles that bomb until the super bowl saved the day. My mistake. But the album was flopping though for Gaga standards & especially to her peers.

I'm saying that clearly MORE FANS are supporting her regular studio albums than her side-projects which is why they don't do as well commercially

Mi reflejo was successful though. It’s ready to be Diamond certified. It’s 6X platinum! It opened the door for her to be International. The singles were massive in Latin America. Fans were begging for a follow up for YEARS!

Burlesque is the only album from the 10s to be certified platinum. It would’ve been more successful if she didn’t jump ship during promotion because of personal reasons.

Say something smash hard 15 years into her career.

So YOU might not support Christina side projects but she does fine. Again PMM is gold & the EP is the second most stream Spanish EP of the year behind Rosalía.

You have shaded Christina for YEARS yet in the same breath say you like her. You have been dragged for it. Stop acting like me calling you out is completely random.

It’s totally fair.