Discuss Beyoncé

Britney's career lasted 1998-2011, while Xtina's lasted from 1999-2014 at least. She hasn't released anything since her smash Say Something, so it's hard to say if she's still able to smash as hard as she did in 2014, but I'm wondering why she managed to outlast her big competitor?

Britney's last hit was forever ago, while Xtina has had numerous hits like Moves Like Jagger, Feel This Moment and Say Something since.

Remember when Britney fans said Xtina was over? It's quite ironic, actually.

17 replies (on page 1 of 2)

Jump to last post

Next pageLast page

Xtine has talent Britney lasted from 1998 to 2004

Lol call me when Xtine gets a SOLO hit. Her career ended in 2007.

At least Britney had #1s in three decades and is still selling out shows worldwide.

@Stacey101 said:

Lol call me when Xtine gets a SOLO hit. Her career ended in 2007.

At least Britney had #1s in three decades and is still selling out shows worldwide.

But aren't you claiming Katy is NOT over because she's got a feature hit right now? expressionless

Make up your damn mind. If Xtina's career ended with her solo hits and her successful features don't count, then same goes for Katy.

@LadyFlopgaCocaineQueen said:

It remains to be seen if Xtina can actually make a solo comeback. (or if she has the drive to) She has what it takes but she needs the right material and the ambition. I swear sometimes I want to give up on her because she is so lazy.

Britney's career is pretty much over but she is the most successful talentless artist of all time so congrats to her I guess. I don't really think she gives a flying fvck either way because she has been a vegetable for 10 years now.

I agree. She's extremely lazy. I hate her thinking it's somehow cool to have fans wait long ass time for a new record. That sh!t got annoying the last 80 times she did it.

She used to have some drive, it's all gone now it seems unamused

Did it though?

@PlasticPrada said:

Did it though?

You're such a double standard.

You claim Katy ain't over because she's a feature on "Feels" despite her solo stuff bombing right now, but Xtina's THREE hit collabs don't count?

MESS.

Gurl pls Xtina hasn't had a hit album since 2006.

@mrjacs said:

@PlasticPrada said:

Did it though?

You're such a double standard.

You claim Katy ain't over because she's a feature on "Feels" despite her solo stuff bombing right now, but Xtina's THREE hit collabs don't count?

MESS.

Are you really comparing Xtinct to Katy?

  • Witness already outsold Bionic and Lotus in just 3 months
  • CTTR outpeaked/outsold the last decade of Xtinct solo stuff
  • Feels went #1 in the UK, something Xtinct hasn't done since 2003
  • Feels has outpeaked ALL of Xtinct's solo singles in the US circa 2007-2012
  • Witness era alone outsold Bionic/Lotus era COMBINED worldwide

Even Katy's flop era is outselling/outpeaking both of Xtine's tank era. MESS indeed.

Ummm let me know when Xtine can sell out a record breaking concert in the Middle East and Asia as the MAIN performer in 2017, and then we can talk. Britney has always had bigger hits, more memorable legacy, and more people checking for her regardless of her past two flop albums. Britney can get another hit song featured and solo if she wanted, and Make Me proved that before the flop video/performances. Xtine can maybe have a feature hit but solo will never happen. If Your Body didn't smash nothing of hers will anymore.

Britney professional career ended after 2004, since then she has been a train wreck. She is a pop culture icon, but so is kimk.

@halomaniac88 said:

Britney professional career ended after 2004, since then she has been a train wreck.

She had her biggest hit in 2009 and her 6th #1 in 2011 though lol

@PlasticPrada said: Are you really comparing Xtinct to Katy?

  • Witness already outsold Bionic and Lotus in just 3 months
  • CTTR outpeaked/outsold the last decade of Xtinct solo stuff
  • Feels went #1 in the UK, something Xtinct hasn't done since 2003
  • Feels has outpeaked ALL of Xtinct's solo singles in the US circa 2007-2012
  • Witness era alone outsold Bionic/Lotus era COMBINED worldwide

Even Katy's flop era is outselling/outpeaking both of Xtine's tank era. MESS indeed.

You're mixing it up too much. You're giving Katy credit and acting like Feels makes her relevant, but didn't do the same when Xtina was smashing with her features and Britney was bombing with her solo stuff. That logic is just extremely dull.

Besides, Katy's singles are tanking as hard as Xtina singles since Bionic. So if both have had solo singles tanking and hit features, how exactly does that make Katy superior?

And MESS at you claiming Bionic sold less. You have to remember Witness' flop sales are NOT only pure sales. You'd get a heart attack if you saw the pure sales for Witness, which are on Lotus-level. Bionic also spent a longer time on the album charts, Katy's was nowhere to be found a little over a month after release bomb

Again, if you say Xtina is over because she hasn't had a solo hit and only has hits with features, why are you not saying the same about Katy?

@Ultraviolenxe said:

@halomaniac88 said:

Britney professional career ended after 2004, since then she has been a train wreck.

She had her biggest hit in 2009 and her 6th #1 in 2011 though lol

GAGGING at anyone saying Xtincta has a longer lasting career when the lazy bitch is doing Oreo commercials while Britney is years into a residency

BUMP

@Gfe said:

BUMP

You're embarrassing yourself even more.

This thread was towards all the Katy stans who claimed Katy wasn't over because she had a feature hit but claimed Xtina's features meant she was over. So it was taking their logic and spinning it on Xtina's collabs man_facepalming_tone1

How stupid are you.

Can't find a movie or TV show? Login to create it.

Global

s focus the search bar
p open profile menu
esc close an open window
? open keyboard shortcut window

On media pages

b go back (or to parent when applicable)
e go to edit page

On TV season pages

(right arrow) go to next season
(left arrow) go to previous season

On TV episode pages

(right arrow) go to next episode
(left arrow) go to previous episode

On all image pages

a open add image window

On all edit pages

t open translation selector
ctrl+ s submit form

On discussion pages

n create new discussion
w toggle watching status
p toggle public/private
c toggle close/open
a open activity
r reply to discussion
l go to last reply
ctrl+ enter submit your message
(right arrow) next page
(left arrow) previous page

Settings

Want to rate or add this item to a list?

Login