Following their ugly breakup, Mitchell and Jack navigate gay life in New York.

Jack gets more than he bargained for when he tries to pick up a stranger in Williamsburg, and Oona decides that revenge is a dish best served in a little black dress.

Jack agrees to pick up a horribly drunk Mitchell from Oona's apartment.

Flashback to the destruction of Jack and Mitchell's relationship.

Oona is unhappy with Russell. Jack and Mitchell take another step in repairing their friendship as Mitchell and Oona have a fight.

An obstacle arises in Jack and Scruffy's relationship, and Oona runs into Drew and his new lover.