Dyskusje Agatha Christie - Dix petits nègres

I congratulate the producers for sticking to the original nihilistic ending, rather than copping out by having two characters both escape and turn out innocent. I'm less happy with some of the back stories, which violate the idea that the guilty characters had escaped legal punishment on technicalities or lack of evidence. In the book, the general sent his wife's lover on a suicide mission and Blore's false testimony put a dying man in jail. In the dramatization, the general shot the lover and Blore beat a prisoner to death -- how did they get away with either crime?

3 odpowiedzi (strona 1 z 1)

Jump to last post

In the middle of the maelstrom of World War I, The General could have ordered his men "over the top," then tossed/moved the body of the Lieutenant nearest the action. With the huge number of corpses piling up, who is going to suspect murder? Even if murder is suspected, how can ordinary medics deduce that the victim was shot "back to front" instead of "front to back"? Rank has it's privileges, so who would question, let alone suspect a senior officer of a low grade crime in war? As for the Detective Sergeant, this is another case of Authority triumphing over Justice. He could hang the "active interrogation" results on another squad of Constables or say that "Short Eyes" got it from unruly prisoners. Mass murderers escape justice every day...

Yes, it could have happened that way, but it doesn't really fit the story. Most of the others were guilty of abusing authority -- the governess let her child go into danger, the old lady bullied a depressed, frightened girl, the doctor did an operation while drunk, the caretakers killed a patient entrusted to their care. To say that Blore and the general committed murder and covered it up sounds like it was imported from another Christie story.

I haven't read the novel, but it seems like the original murders are better than the show's... Although the show wasn't bad at all..

Nie możesz znaleźć filmu lub serialu? Zaloguj się, aby go utworzyć.

Globalny

s zaznacz pasek wyszukiwania
p otwórz menu profilu
esc Zamknij otwarte okno
? otwórz okno skrótów klawiszowych

On media pages

b go back (or to parent when applicable)
e przejdź do strony edycji

On TV season pages

(prawa strzałka) przejdź do następnego sezonu
(lewa strzałka) przejdź do poprzedniego sezonu

On TV episode pages

(prawa strzałka) przejdź do następnego odcinka
(lewa strzałka) przejdź do poprzedniego odcinka

On all image pages

a otwórz okno dodawania obrazu

On all edit pages

t open translation selector
ctrl+ s prześlij formularz

On discussion pages

n otwórz nową dyskusję
w toggle watching status
p toggle public/private
c toggle close/open
a open activity
r odpowiedz na dyskusję
l przejdź do ostatniej odpowiedzi
ctrl+ enter wyślij swoją wiadomość
(prawa strzałka) następna strona
(lewa strzałka) poprzednia strona

Ustawienia

Want to rate or add this item to a list?

Zaloguj