The best directing, cinematography, and acting this show has seen. Definitely the best episode of the season, with a pretty good script and intriguing story to tie it all up. Kudos to the production design as well. Feels very Season One. This and Heartless are tied for best episode of the season. Felt like a mystery film.

However, the "twist" of the murder was subpar, when I thought it was SPOILERS George, but when it was Hook I thought it was better than if they revealed it originally. It was a very well done red herring. END SPOILERS.

The Pleasure Island scenes were poor. However, the delivery was well for the George-David scenes and the murder scene. Worried they will write themselves into a corner. The promo looks AMAZING tho.

However, the SPOILERS Robin not being who he seems is very interesting. END SPOILERS

Regina is gradually growing on me. Liked seeing August again.

7.5/10