We are searching data from the original broadcast. They are not necessary set on the DVD the same way that they were originally broadcasted.

I'm not sure what proof existed for The Christmas Special to be broken out into two episodes. This episode listing is wrong. I don't know what to do to meet the requirements for moderation.

@superboy97 said:

We are searching data from the original broadcast. They are not necessary set on the DVD the same way that they were originally broadcasted.

TV Guide season 4 listing: https://www.tvguide.com/tvshows/regular-show/episodes-season-4/1000445332/

I made a report on these two part listings in the past https://www.themoviedb.org/tv/31132-regular-show/discuss/66a5fabbcff3d8b77a6a7bc9 however, I guess its still in the queue to be action-ed. As you are new here its always good to check for previous reports before creating new ones.

Also, I noticed you edited/vandalised season 3 which is now a complete mess with episodes out of order and aired dates changed. Please stop with these bad edits and if you are unsure create a report, changing orders is REALLY bad and has knock on effects to products which scrap from tmdb. Your bad edits will effect MANY users ...

EDIT: 30-Dec-2024: I have reverted the bad edits made to season 3. The editor used this listing https://www.tvguide.com/tvshows/regular-show/episodes-season-4/1000445332 which has incorrect data and are not the first airings of episodes. Checking many other online sites including https://regularshow.fandom.com/wiki/List_of_Regular_Show_episodes#Season_3_(2011-2012) they had the same data tmdb had before these edits so I have reverted them.

@markcurrancavan said:

I made a report on these two part listings in the past https://www.themoviedb.org/tv/31132-regular-show/discuss/66a5fabbcff3d8b77a6a7bc9 however, I guess its still in the queue to be action-ed. As you are new here its always good to check for previous reports before creating new ones.

Also, I noticed you edited/vandalised season 3 which is now a complete mess with episodes out of order and aired dates changed. Please stop with these bad edits and if you are unsure create a report, changing orders is REALLY bad and has knock on effects to products which scrap from tmdb. Your bad edits will effect MANY users ...

EDIT: 30-Dec-2024: I have reverted the bad edits made to season 3. The editor used this listing https://www.tvguide.com/tvshows/regular-show/episodes-season-4/1000445332 which has incorrect data and are not the first airings of episodes. Checking many other online sites including https://regularshow.fandom.com/wiki/List_of_Regular_Show_episodes#Season_3_(2011-2012) they had the same data tmdb had before these edits so I have reverted them.

You're original thread was closed so I made a new one.

This site moves too slow. The existing episode listing for the seasons is messing up things, but nobody has proof of one way or the other. To state I vandalized the information is a bit of a serious accusation.

I've more or less stopped ripping my collection of Regular Show for Plex because I'm tired of using "hacks" to get the episodes to be ordered right (i.e., using s03e05-06 to indicate it spans two "episodes" from tmdb). Just like you've commented, the current wrong listing of things that has yet to be corrected for 6 months is having knock on effects for Plex Media Server which defaults to using TMDB for the metadata agent.

@markcurrancavan said:

I made a report on these two part listings in the past https://www.themoviedb.org/tv/31132-regular-show/discuss/66a5fabbcff3d8b77a6a7bc9 however, I guess its still in the queue to be action-ed. As you are new here its always good to check for previous reports before creating new ones.

Also, I noticed you edited/vandalised season 3 which is now a complete mess with episodes out of order and aired dates changed. Please stop with these bad edits and if you are unsure create a report, changing orders is REALLY bad and has knock on effects to products which scrap from tmdb. Your bad edits will effect MANY users ...

EDIT: 30-Dec-2024: I have reverted the bad edits made to season 3. The editor used this listing https://www.tvguide.com/tvshows/regular-show/episodes-season-4/1000445332 which has incorrect data and are not the first airings of episodes. Checking many other online sites including https://regularshow.fandom.com/wiki/List_of_Regular_Show_episodes#Season_3_(2011-2012) they had the same data tmdb had before these edits so I have reverted them.

As SuperBoy97 will comment, a fan-run website isn't an official source for episode listings. Per them, they need official broadcast records (wherever one gets that from). TV Guide is arguably more accurate than a fan-ran website as they used to print out listing books to see what shows were coming on and when. This was back in the 90's and early 2000's before we had things like Tivo and cable TV guides. Not sure if they still print those guides, but the website is still updated with current and future airings of TV shows.

If you dig into the Fandom episode list more, also, the episode listing lines up with TVDB. They don't have the specials split and longer episodes split into two episodes.

@TheMet4lGod said:

As SuperBoy97 will comment, a fan-run website isn't an official source for episode listings. Per them, they need official broadcast records (wherever one gets that from). TV Guide is arguably more accurate than a fan-ran website as they used to print out listing books to see what shows were coming on and when. This was back in the 90's and early 2000's. Not sure if they still print those guides.

As explained here on their site, tvguide.com site has nothing to do with the company that edit the TV magazines, except the fact that it use the name.

This is simply a site that gather informations from Internet. On a scale of reliability, tvguide.com is much worst than a fandom dedicated to a single series and run by fans that do dedicate research about a specific series.

You're original thread was closed so I made a new one.

My thread is still open -> https://www.themoviedb.org/tv/31132-regular-show/discuss/66a5fabbcff3d8b77a6a7bc9, its not closed!

This site moves too slow. The existing episode listing for the seasons is messing up things, but nobody has proof of one way or the other. To state I vandalized the information is a bit of a serious accusation.

Yes the site moves slowly but that's the nature of volunteer based moderators. I do myself wish things got sorted faster but it is what it is.

Yes you did vandalised the information. You, unilaterally decided what was here was wrong and just changed it. If you have facts then raise a thread and lets have it reviewed but just changing it effecting every other user who references this episode listing to match what YOU believe is correct is not the way to go about it.

Also, the fandom site was only one reference here are two more https://www.thetvdb.com/series/regular-show/seasons/official/3 and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Regular_Show_episodes#Episodes both of which also listing the original air dates that tmdb use which is a total of 4 using the same set of air dates.

Are all these pieces of the same information from multiple difference sources 100% accurate, I cannot say with absolute certainty. However, without additional proof changing to something else (which you did) is not the way to go about it.

Just like you've commented, the current wrong listing of things that has yet to be corrected for 6 months is having knock on effects for Plex Media Server which defaults to using TMDB for the metadata agent.

You do know you can use episode ordering within plex and you can set it to tvdb DVD listings ? Just use that if you want DVD listings for this show.

@superboy97 said:

@TheMet4lGod said:

As SuperBoy97 will comment, a fan-run website isn't an official source for episode listings. Per them, they need official broadcast records (wherever one gets that from). TV Guide is arguably more accurate than a fan-ran website as they used to print out listing books to see what shows were coming on and when. This was back in the 90's and early 2000's. Not sure if they still print those guides.

As explained here on their site, tvguide.com site has nothing to do with the company that edit the TV magazines, except the fact that it use the name.

This is simply a site that gather informations from Internet. On a scale of reliability, tvguide.com is much worst than a fandom dedicated to a single series and run by fans that do dedicate research about a specific series.

On that premise, then, can we please remove the part 1 and part 2 episodes and wrap up the original content issue dokuro created 6-7 months ago?

What's more, if we can trust the fandom episode listing information then the final episode needs to be 3 parts as it has 3 production codes instead of a two-parter with "The Power" again as the final episode.

@markcurrancavan said:

You're original thread was closed so I made a new one.

My thread is still open -> https://www.themoviedb.org/tv/31132-regular-show/discuss/66a5fabbcff3d8b77a6a7bc9, its not closed!

This site moves too slow. The existing episode listing for the seasons is messing up things, but nobody has proof of one way or the other. To state I vandalized the information is a bit of a serious accusation.

Yes the site moves slowly but that's the nature of volunteer based moderators. I do myself wish things got sorted faster but it is what it is.

Yes you did vandalised the information. You, unilaterally decided what was here was wrong and just changed it. If you have facts then raise a thread and lets have it reviewed but just changing it effecting every other user who references this episode listing to match what YOU believe is correct is not the way to go about it.

Also, the fandom site was only one reference here are two more https://www.thetvdb.com/series/regular-show/seasons/official/3 and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Regular_Show_episodes#Episodes both of which also listing the original air dates that tmdb use which is a total of 4 using the same set of air dates.

Are all these pieces of the same information from multiple difference sources 100% accurate, I cannot say with absolute certainty. However, without additional proof changing to something else (which you did) is not the way to go about it.

Just like you've commented, the current wrong listing of things that has yet to be corrected for 6 months is having knock on effects for Plex Media Server which defaults to using TMDB for the metadata agent.

You do know you can use episode ordering within plex and you can set it to tvdb DVD listings ? Just use that if you want DVD listings for this show.

Vandalism implies malicious intent. If you're going to accuse me of vandalizing instead of just making bad/poor edits, then I want to know what justification you have for making that accusation. Your point of "made changes because I could" doesn't constitute vandalism. Arguably, by the nature of how this site works, if it's not locked it's free to edit. If something needs to be preserved, then it should be locked. This is no different than Waze where we lock things for lower level editors to prevent random people from making modifications either maliciously or erroneously. I think you owe me an apology for throwing out a serious accusation of vandalism versus just saying I am making erroneous edits.

There needs to be more clarity in the editing/contribution guidelines on what sources are considered acceptable or not. Not just for my sake, but for others. There are several other older threads where people are citing wrong episodes that are disregarded because it's not an "official source". And what constitutes an episode being a multi-parter? Just the simple fact there were different production codes even though it only aired as one episode (I watched most of these on TV when they aired). I do other volunteer contributions on services like Waze and OpenStreetMap and, by comparison, the guidelines for this site are very basic.

As for the Plex server, I'll look into it again but there was a reason I wasn't using the TVDB metadata source. I remember there being issues with it not recognizing episodes or something, but it has been a while. Either way, I don't think that excuses the wrong information listed here.

We have finally be able to find proof;

• Based on this press release, it seems that "Exit 9B" should be a single episode.
• Based on this press release, it seems that "Terror Tales of the Park II" should be a single episode.
• Based on this press release, it seems that "The Christmas Special" should be a single episode.

Thank you for looking into it. As a suggestion for future maintenance, we should probably lock the episode ordering to prevent someone from changing it back.