Thirty years ago, a newlywed couple were murdered at the Cold River Motel in a satanic ritual; a group of true crime enthusiasts have been invited to the motel's reopening, where they discover history might be repeating itself.

Trapped by the raging storm and unable to call for help, the guests retreat to their rooms, uncertain who among them is the killer. Meanwhile, two strangers seeking shelter hide their true identities from the others.

When the storm temporarily subsides, the guests attempt to leave the motel and find help. Others try to figure out who the other killer might be.

The guests grow more suspicious when the driver that brought them there days earlier shows up at their doorstep. His presence causes a rift between the men and women, leading to a violent outburst with devastating consequences.

Triggered by a gruesome discovery, one the surviving guests goes mad, haunted by his own traumatic past.

The surviving guests team up to stop a satanic ritual after discovering the true identities of the killers.

Things culminate in a bloody finale at the premiere of a new film based on the Cold River Motel.