Series Cast 87

1. 

   Amber Tamblyn

   Joan Girardi (22 Episodes)

2. 

   Joe Mantegna

   Will Girardi (22 Episodes)

3. 

   Mary Steenburgen

   Helen Girardi (22 Episodes)

4. 

   Jason Ritter

   Kevin Girardi (22 Episodes)

5. 

   Michael Welch

   Luke Girardi (22 Episodes)

6. 

   Christopher Rodriguez Marquette

   Adam Rove (22 Episodes)

7. 

   Becky Wahlstrom

   Grace Polk (22 Episodes)

8. 

   Aaron Himelstein

   Friedman (19 Episodes)

9. 

   Mageina Tovah

   Glynis Figliola (12 Episodes)

10. 

    Mark Totty

    Det. Carlisle (12 Episodes)

11. 

    Annie Potts

    Lieutenant Lucy Preston (11 Episodes)

12. 

    Constance Zimmer

    Sister Lilly Watters (11 Episodes)

13. 

    Sprague Grayden

    Judith Montgomery (9 Episodes)

14. 

    Jeffrey Licon

    Goth Kid God (5 Episodes)

15. 

    Patrick Fabian

    Gavin Price (5 Episodes)

16. 

    Elaine Hendrix

    Ms. Lischak (5 Episodes)

17. 

    Kimberly McCullough

    Beth Reinhart (5 Episodes)

18. 

    Kathryn Joosten

    Old Lady God (5 Episodes)

19. 

    Riley Smith

    Andy Baker (5 Episodes)

20. 

    Mike Starr

    Big Tough Guy God (4 Episodes)

21. 

    Juliette Goglia

    Little Girl God (4 Episodes)

22. 

    Jack Plotnick

    The Other Sammy (4 Episodes)

23. 

    David Burke

    Father Ken Mallory (4 Episodes)

24. 

    Haylie Duff

    Stevie Marx (3 Episodes)

25. 

    Kris Lemche

    Cute Boy God (3 Episodes)

26. 

    Paul Sand

    Rabbi Polonski (2 Episodes)

27. 

    Alexis Dziena

    Bonnie (2 Episodes)

28. 

    Corri English

    Elizabeth Goetzman (2 Episodes)

29. 

    Evan Handler

    Chuck Kroner (2 Episodes)

30. Charlie Koznick

    Ryan (2 Episodes)

31. 

    Diane Delano

    Coach Carol Keady (2 Episodes)

32. 

    Christopher Cousins

    Tom Murphy (2 Episodes)

33. 

    Wentworth Miller

    Ryan Hunter (2 Episodes)

34. 

    Kevin Rahm

    Dana Tuchman (2 Episodes)

35. 

    Tara Lynne Barr

    Jump-Rope Girl (uncredited) (1 Episode)

36. 

    Vanessa Bell Calloway

    Corey Phillips (1 Episode)

37. 

    Christy Carlson Romano

    Officious Hall Monitor God (1 Episode)

38. 

    Sam Horrigan

    Tommy Belkin (1 Episode)

39. 

    James Russo

    James Karon (1 Episode)

40. 

    Lauren C. Mayhew

    Elle (1 Episode)

41. 

    Russ Tamblyn

    Dog Walker God (1 Episode)

42. 

    Trevor Einhorn

    Mascot God (1 Episode)

43. 

    Dayo Ade

    Ruben (1 Episode)

44. 

    Kristy Wu

    Annie (1 Episode)

45. 

    Rae Allen

    Fortune Teller God (1 Episode)

46. 

    John Marshall Jones

    Chess Player God (1 Episode)

47. 

    Michael Badalucco

    Father Payne (1 Episode)

48. 

    Al Mancini

    Grandpa God (1 Episode)

49. 

    James DuMont

    George Lane (1 Episode)

50. 

    Veanne Cox

    Personable Woman God (1 Episode)

51. 

    Austin Pendleton

    Dietrich Steinholz (1 Episode)

52. 

    Patrick Breen

    Sammy (1 Episode)

53. 

    Rick Overton

    Bad Stand-Up Comedian God (1 Episode)

54. 

    Jayne Atkinson

    Fran Montgomery (1 Episode)

55. 

    Megan Henning

    Darlene Fitch (1 Episode)

56. 

    Allyce Beasley

    Woman with Cats God (1 Episode)

57. 

    Mike Erwin

    Lars Klosterman (1 Episode)

58. 

    Kate Norby

    Dr. Jennifer Davis (1 Episode)

59. 

    Iqbal Theba

    East Indian Sunglasses Salesman God (1 Episode)

60. 

    Petrea Burchard

    Catherine Lee (1 Episode)

61. 

    will.i.am

    Three Card Monte Guy God (1 Episode)

62. 

    Zachary Quinto

    Pretentious Filmmaker God (1 Episode)

63. 

    David Marciano

    Edmond Dodds (1 Episode)

64. 

    Aaron Frazier

    Basketball Player God (1 Episode)

65. 

    Nancy Lenehan

    Erica Marx (1 Episode)

66. 

    Adam Wylie

    Skinny Kid God (1 Episode)

67. 

    Tyler Kain

    Gabby (1 Episode)

68. 

    Sarah Lilly

    Nora (1 Episode)

69. 

    Armin Shimerman

    Ronald Harbison (1 Episode)

70. 

    Hilary Duff

    Dylan Samuels (1 Episode)

71. 

    Rolando Molina

    Trash Man God (1 Episode)

72. 

    John Patrick Amedori

    Loner Loser Kid God (1 Episode)

73. 

    Robert Pine

    Mr. Baker (1 Episode)

74. 

    Mark L. Taylor

    Salesman God (1 Episode)

75. Sam Murphy

    Donny (1 Episode)

76. 

    Matthew McKane

    Beasley (1 Episode)

77. 

    Courtney Hope

    Chelsea (1 Episode)

78. 

    Joyce Guy

    Judge Patricia Claymore (1 Episode)

79. 

    Kitty Swink

    Annette Langston (1 Episode)

80. 

    Mary Mara

    Sarah Polonski (1 Episode)

81. 

    Larry Hankin

    Homeless Man God (1 Episode)

82. 

    Yorgo Constantine

    Vladamir Karpovic (1 Episode)

83. 

    David Dorfman

    Rocky Tardio (1 Episode)

84. Cee Cee Michaela

    Audra (1 Episode)

85. 

    Cal Gibson

    Groundskeeper God (1 Episode)

86. 

    Aaron Paul

    Denunzio (1 Episode)

87. 

    Michael J. Willett

    Billy (1 Episode)

Series Crew 25