@BobPeters61 said:

Personally, I like the first dress she tried on best. However, considering what we've seen of the character and her tastes, I wouldn't expect her or Sheldon not to be most drawn to that pile of doilies.

Once I saw it, I just knew that it would be her choice, and that Sheldon would be blown away on first sight of it.

Because, as Sheldon's mother noted, they're both weirdoes.

@Knixon said:

Does it really seem out of character for Amy to pick a wedding dress that others might regard as hideous? Especially considering how she dresses usually? It also doesn't seem that far out that Sheldon would find it beautiful too.

But she loved the first one she tried on, Penny even told her don't choose the first one you try on.

No doubt Penny expected she would find and pick something else even better, not something horrible.

The question remains why the show would go with such a dumb joke. Ha Ha Amy is so needy she takes fashion advice from no fashion sense Sheldon not her fashion aware Besties. Lame.

Gotta be "realistic" though. If wearing a Gorn costume is what got Sheldon ready to boink, that's what she would do.