@LadyGigi said:

Apparently Negan's crew found the gun storage trap that the garbage people set up in that house off the lake and the garbage people tracked them down like they did with Father Gabriel and Rick. Then Jadis told them about Rick's plans for the war. So Negan made a better deal with Jadis and formed an alliance.

But Rick promised her a third of everything the Saviors had! How is twelve people (reduced to ten) a better deal? Plus you know the garbage people are going to be under Negan's thumb now. Jadis is incredibly naive to think she can cut a single deal with him, then go back to their trash heap and carry on as before. The Saviors don't tolerate independent communities within their territory (which is always expanding). How stupid are the garbage people not to see that revealing themselves to Negan was a big mistake? No one bothers exploring a landfill. They could've stayed under the radar for a long time.

@chrisjdel said:

@chrisjdel said:

@LadyGigi said:

Apparently Negan's crew found the gun storage trap that the garbage people set up in that house off the lake and the garbage people tracked them down like they did with Father Gabriel and Rick. Then Jadis told them about Rick's plans for the war. So Negan made a better deal with Jadis and formed an alliance.

But Rick promised her a third of everything the Saviors had! How is twelve people (reduced to ten) a better deal? Plus you know the garbage people are going to be under Negan's thumb now. Jadis is incredibly naive to think she can cut a single deal with him, then go back to their trash heap and carry on as before. The Saviors don't tolerate independent communities within their territory (which is always expanding). How stupid are the garbage people not to see that revealing themselves to Negan was a big mistake? No one bothers exploring a landfill. They could've stayed under the radar for a long time, even if Rick and his alliance lost the war.

The writing.

maybe negan promised them alexandria in addition to 12 people.

It was freaking Jadis. Why the debate when she told Rick what happened like right after she betrayed him? Question asked and answered.

Gregory knew nothing about the details of their plans...so it wasn't him.

@Nubyan said:

@beith1 said:

i think gregory

Isn't it obvious that it was the garbage pale group?

Isn't it obvious that this thread was created BEFORE the finale aired... look at the date!!!

@theModernLeper said: Isn't it obvious that this thread was created BEFORE the finale aired... look at the date!!!

The OP should lock the thread now.

@theModernLeper said:

Isn't it obvious that this thread was created BEFORE the finale aired... look at the date!!!

Isn't it obvious that I responded to a reply from someone dated April 3rd?

However, in case it isnt...I was.

@Nubyan said:

Isn't it obvious that I responded to a reply from someone dated April 3rd?

However, in case it isnt...I was.

What are you talking about?! Your first post (you know, the one I quoted?!) was in direct reply to the original poster, who asked the question and gave their prediction on the 26th of March, you literally quoted that prediction and chimed in with your condescending "Isn't it obvious that it was the garbage pale group?". Despite the fact that at the time of that post the episode hadn't even aired yet!

But if you want to talk about your second post on the 3rd, it's equally ridiculous because no-one was debating who it was, people were simply discussing the reasoning of why Jadis made a seemingly illogical deal with Negan... also since the episode has aired no-one has claimed that it was Gregory

@theModernLeper said:

@Nubyan said:

Isn't it obvious that I responded to a reply from someone dated April 3rd?

However, in case it isnt...I was.

What are you talking about?! Your first post (you know, the one I quoted?!) was in direct reply to the original poster, who asked the question and gave their prediction on the 26th of March, you literally quoted that prediction and chimed in with your condescending "Isn't it obvious that it was the garbage pale group?". Despite the fact that at the time of that post the episode hadn't even aired yet!

But if you want to talk about your second post on the 3rd, it's equally ridiculous because no-one was debating who it was, people were simply discussing the reasoning of why Jadis made a seemingly illogical deal with Negan... also since the episode has aired no-one has claimed that it was Gregory

I saw that error on my part. But what I did was go to the discussion board and look at the date of a post. Although, it started in March some time, the last post date was April 3rd. Which is why I joined the thread. When I quoted Beth, I didn't look at the original post date. So, can you understand my error?

@Nubyan said:

I saw that error on my part. But what I did was go to the discussion board and look at the date of a post. Although, it started in March some time, the last post date was April 3rd. Which is why I joined the thread. When I quoted Beth, I didn't look at the original post date. So, can you understand my error?

Understood, fair enough. Nested threads on this site would help.

@beith1 said:

i think gregory

Jadis