讨论 The Walking Dead
讨论 → 节目 → The Walking Dead → 一般问题
What type of society would you prefer?
TheShredderSTAFFMOD 发布于 2017 年 03 月 21 日 2:14下午
Ricks: Marxist Socialist
Negans: Capitalism at its finest
Horus Mazinga 的回复
于 2017 年 03 月 21 日 2:36下午
I was thinking about this.
Other than the cruelty and the multiple wives, Negan's rule is a pretty good model for societal recovery. This is assuming that that he actually provides security from walkers and other marauding humans (which is implied but we never see). Negan has been very fair in his treatment. Rules and consequences.
Lose the multi-wife thing and station a guard or two at each town so that they don't have to devote time/effort to defending themselves and you have a justification for a tax.
The socialism depends to much on overachievers and is only as strong as its weakest link. OK for rudimentary survival but doomed in any long term structure.
So Rick's rule was best at the onset of the Zpoc but a softer Negan style is better for recovery.
jonnieblack 的回复
于 2017 年 03 月 21 日 10:50下午
Team Rick. Always team Rick.
chrisjdel 的回复
于 2017 年 03 月 22 日 8:44上午
Alexandria isn't really big enough to attach an -ism to the way it's run. It's more like a large family or a gang than anything else.
Most people at the Sanctuary are basically serfs working for the ruling nobility, with Negan at the very top as dictator. There's no competition or free market. It's a feudal system.
TheShredder 的回复
于 2017 年 03 月 22 日 9:30上午
Very well put, I stand corrected. If there were free market, Negan and his Saviors would turn it into a turf war and become more like the Mafia.
tmdb38541732 的回复
于 2017 年 03 月 22 日 12:31下午
I thought that's what The Saviors were more like that along: An organized crime syndicate in a zombie apocalypse setting.