Lol, nice try with the False Dilemma fallacy.

@chrisjdel said:

@TheShredder said:

I need a brick wall to bang my head on. I think that would be more enjoyable than having this redundant conversation. I've said my piece. I'm done.

So you'd put everyone in the Hilltop and Alexandria in danger just to avoid killing a treacherous prick like Gregory? Great plan. Remind me never to vote for you as leader! If Negan learns that Rick is trying to start a revolution he won't just kill one or two people, both communities will be burned to the ground.

No, I doubt Negan will burn both communitities down. He's not like Alpha and the Whisperers. Negan would just killed a few more people from those communities thereby making finding people to scavenge more difficult.

@LadyGigi said:

@chrisjdel said:

@TheShredder said:

I need a brick wall to bang my head on. I think that would be more enjoyable than having this redundant conversation. I've said my piece. I'm done.

So you'd put everyone in the Hilltop and Alexandria in danger just to avoid killing a treacherous prick like Gregory? Great plan. Remind me never to vote for you as leader! If Negan learns that Rick is trying to start a revolution he won't just kill one or two people, both communities will be burned to the ground.

No, I doubt Negan will burn both communitities down. He's not like Alpha and the Whisperers. Negan would just killed a few more people from those communities thereby making finding people to scavenge more difficult.

Someone posted a link to one of the Walking Dead comics, in which Negan learns that Rick is putting together an alliance against him - and then launches a grenade attack against Alexandria burning at least a sizable portion of it. Rick Grimes and his people have proven they can't be trusted or controlled and are determined to destroy him no matter what it takes. They've been pretending to yield while plotting a war behind his back. It's possible Negan would only kill a small group of people at the Hilltop, but he'd go for the jugular with Alexandria.

@chrisjdel said:

@LadyGigi said:

@chrisjdel said:

@TheShredder said:

I need a brick wall to bang my head on. I think that would be more enjoyable than having this redundant conversation. I've said my piece. I'm done.

So you'd put everyone in the Hilltop and Alexandria in danger just to avoid killing a treacherous prick like Gregory? Great plan. Remind me never to vote for you as leader! If Negan learns that Rick is trying to start a revolution he won't just kill one or two people, both communities will be burned to the ground.

No, I doubt Negan will burn both communitities down. He's not like Alpha and the Whisperers. Negan would just killed a few more people from those communities thereby making finding people to scavenge more difficult.

Someone posted a link to one of the Walking Dead comics, in which Negan learns that Rick is putting together an alliance against him - and then launches a grenade attack against Alexandria burning at least a sizable portion of it. Rick Grimes and his people have proven they can't be trusted or controlled and are determined to destroy him no matter what it takes. They've been pretending to yield while plotting a war behind his back. It's possible Negan would only kill a small group of people at the Hilltop, but he'd go for the jugular with Alexandria.

Well yeah. But that was after Rick and the other communities started all out war with the Saviors. In fact that's the title of that story arch: All Out War. Before then is leadinf up to it with March To War.

Rick and them launched first WARNING attack. Negan tries to regain control by cohersing Gregory to get the Hilltop under control and not support Alexandria. But that doesn't work. Negan loses control of the situation. War begins, then Negan rallies the Saviors together and counter attack- the grenade launcher and weapons smeared in the infected's blood.

We aren't at that point yet in the show. The plots in the show build/lead up to that moment as well as what happens with the Gregory and Maggie power struggle.

So first Negan is going to kill a few more people. That just makes it worse off for him though. But Negan would never completely go unhinged and burn down communities that he thinks he still has some sort of control over and can reason with them. But once his opponents start a war with him, he won't punk out. He'll hit as hard as possible. War is war. Right now, Negan doesn't know war is coming and if he did, he would still try to regain control. Which is what he does in the comic after the first assault Rick coordinates against the Sanctuary.