Discuss Beyoncé

Didn't think I'd be doing a thread like this for this song this early but in response to Rules' thread, I think we need to clarify some things. Hold My Hand debuts with 900k+ streams without any playlist push or music video and promo. Here's a comparison to other soundtracks:

Lady Gaga: Hold My Hand - 905,083

Taylor Swift: Beautiful Ghosts - 594,487

Beyonce: Be Alive - 638,576

Beyonce: Spirit - 680,000

Shallow: 519,590

Just before anyone starts spinning false info, this is how it actually looks like. It's doing decent numbers. There's also clearly more interest in SoundtrackGa than her peers when they do soundtracks, so she's clearly doing something right slight_smile

9 replies (on page 1 of 1)

Jump to last post

@mrjacs said:

Didn't think I'd be doing a thread like this for this song this early but in response to Rules' thread, I think we need to clarify some things. Hold My Hand debuts with 900k+ streams without any playlist push or music video and promo. Here's a comparison to other soundtracks:

Lady Gaga: Hold My Hand - 905,083

Taylor Swift: Beautiful Ghosts - 594,487

Beyonce: Be Alive - 638,576

Beyonce: Spirit - 680,000

Shallow: 500,000

Just before anyone starts spinning false info, this is how it actually looks like. It's doing decent numbers. There's also clearly more interest in SoundtrackGa than her peers when they do soundtracks, so she's clearly doing something right slight_smile

Out of curiosity why did you leave out Katy Electric & Xtina’s We Remain in the line up?

@Rulee said:

Out of curiosity why did you leave out Katy Electric & Xtina’s We Remain in the line up?

Katy's Electric was added to TTH on Spotify and had a 40M playlist reach, being added to over 150 playlists. Hold My Hand has a 4M playlist reach so far, so Katy's song did absolutely horrendous compared to Hold My Hand.

We Remain Issa bop but I don't know what her stats are.

Hold My Hand debuts with 900k+ streams without any playlist push or music video and promo

Katy's Electric was added to TTH on Spotify and had a 40M playlist reach, being added to over 150 playlists. Hold My Hand has a 4M playlist reach so far, so Katy's song did absolutely horrendous compared to Hold My Hand.

I’m not looking for drama but this sounds like a bunch of tired excuses.

Actually no, Gaga numbers are horrendous. You literally told all of us we were pressed because Gaga was relevant.

Gaga should be doing better numbers than this.

@Rulee said:

I’m not looking for drama but this sounds like a bunch of tired excuses.

https://i.imgur.com/ZLRmopo.png

https://i.imgur.com/uGjljSx.png

It literally seems like you are looking for drama. I give you receipts now, perhaps that can calm you down. It's a fact that Katy's song did BOMB with 158 playlists and 40M reach, while Gaga's has been added to four playlists.

Actually no, Gaga numbers are horrendous. You literally told all of us we were pressed because Gaga was relevant.

So Ariana is irrelevant as well? Beyoncé? Taylor Swift? They all opened lower than Gaga. Please explain.

You jumped in to this board and hurried to make a thread about her opening numbers before her own stans. You're the first one who started a HMH chart discussion, so here you have it. If Gaga isn't relevant based on these numbers then neither are Ariana, Taylor or Beyoncé. Or Katy.

I'm kinda surprised that Gaga's HMH did those numbers just from posting on Instagram lol. Ha power crown

Right now, for a song released on a Tuesday without promo or music video, these are decent numbers. They are better than Shallow's first day, for crying out loud.

Don't get mad but you seem like the type who wants and waits for Gaga to stumble on any given occasion and are thrilled about it. Don't be like that slight_smile

Don't get mad but you seem like the type who wants and waits for Gaga to stumble on any given occasion and are thrilled about it.

This is disgusting to say because it’s far from the truth. I literally praised the song upon release.

You just don’t like any criticism towards Gaga. You explode each time. Chill!

I made this thread like i did with tons of others not just her.

@Rulee said:

You just don’t like any criticism towards Gaga. You explode each time. Chill!

I made this thread like i did with tons of others not just her.

Did I explode when you criticized HMH? No. Others have also criticized, no problem. It's the fact that you tend to focus on her sales, chart positions and Spotify monthly listeners as well. Again, no problem as long as you stick to the facts and don't get too angry if someone calls you out for it slight_smile

It's the fact that you tend to focus on her sales, chart positions and Spotify monthly listeners

Again this is a HUGE LIE! I made a post about Gaga rating her albums like the other pop girls. I made ONE post regarding her “new song” debut suddenly it’s focus?

If any other MPG pop girls released this week i would have done the same.

You have a serious issue with accepting Criticism towards Gaga & no just because you ignored it from others recently doesn’t magically make your heartbreaking issue go away.

@Rulee said:

I made ONE post regarding her “new song” debut suddenly it’s focus?

But isn't that because it just came out? slight_smile

It seems like you're more invested in Gaga's single and its performance than other girls. It's okay, post as much as you want and whenever you want. I'm just saying you should post facts, best with receipts. Hopefully you get what I mean relaxed

It seems like you're more invested in Gaga's single and its performance than other girls.

What other MPG has released recently? Did you want me to post Ava Max new single?

Can't find a movie or TV show? Login to create it.

Global

s focus the search bar
p open profile menu
esc close an open window
? open keyboard shortcut window

On media pages

b go back (or to parent when applicable)
e go to edit page

On TV season pages

(right arrow) go to next season
(left arrow) go to previous season

On TV episode pages

(right arrow) go to next episode
(left arrow) go to previous episode

On all image pages

a open add image window

On all edit pages

t open translation selector
ctrl+ s submit form

On discussion pages

n create new discussion
w toggle watching status
p toggle public/private
c toggle close/open
a open activity
r reply to discussion
l go to last reply
ctrl+ enter submit your message
(right arrow) next page
(left arrow) previous page

Settings

Want to rate or add this item to a list?

Login