So does that mean the "mega bomb" Witness was her Artpop era and this "flop" start to KP5 her Joanne?

@PlasticPrada said:

So does that mean the "mega bomb" Witness was her Artpop era and this "flop" start to KP5 her Joanne?

No, Witness is still the mega bomb. Has it crossed 300k in the US alone?

Witness' total hasn't been able to match Joanne's sales before the Super Bowl ever happened, let alone ARTPOP.

@PlasticPrada said:

So does that mean the "mega bomb" Witness was her Artpop era and this "flop" start to KP5 her Joanne?

At least ppl consider Witness a good album can’t say the same for the other one.

@LadyFlopgaCocaineQueen said:

Cool....are you still doing the PURE only sales thing again when talking about Witness? You love to talk PURE sales when it comes to Witness even though you don't usually do that for most albums.

Pure sales or not, Joanne outsold without needing the Super Bowl

Also is Bon Appetit the single still "the biggest bomb ever from a pop girl" as you said even though it outsold and outcharted Gaga singles like GUY and TIHTY both in the US and WW? We started this conversation in another thread and you started giving excuses about GUY being a third single and blah blah blah even though you never said anything like that when you originally made the claim about Bon Appetit....

Yes, a hugely promoted SECOND single from an UNRELEASED album barely outsold G.U.Y - a third single given basically no single treatment

At least Gaga charts when she releases a song like TIHTY. What's Katy's Waving Through A Window's excuse?

@LadyFlopgaCocaineQueen said:

Missing the point. The POINT is your manipulative double standards and BS.

This is EXACTLY your behavior, old man. You go around having criterias yourself about MR only charting because of the Super Bowl but still not being a "hit" in your dusted book, but then you do not use this logic when talking about why Bomb Appetite despite being a big flop did better than G.U.Y.

It was NOT promoted while BA was whored out. Without those TV performances BA would've been as big of a bomb as G.U.Y. But it's still a flop. So take your own advice, crypt-keeper

I've never even heard of that song so I googled it. That wasn't even a single you desperate bitch. Anyway congrats on TIHTY being the biggest flop by a pop girl of all time.

The desperation is YOU acting like TIHTY was treated the same way as a single from an official album/era. No limits for double standards I see Any way, there's 365 so I guess that's the biggest flop by a pop girl. Oh, and then there's Hey Hey Hey.

@LadyFlopgaCocaineQueen said:

I have NEVER said Million Discounts wasn't a hit though you fvcking liar. I have said it was a (local) hit many times due to the Super Bowl. You however were calling Bon Appetit the biggest bomb ever by a pop girl in spite of it doing better than GUY and the oscar bait rape flip-flop song.

You've downplayed its success, tra_nny. Stop it. GUY had no right to be as "successful" as Bomb Appetite since it didn't receive a fraction of its promo.

Are you fvcking retarded? You say BA is the biggest bomb single ever by a pop girl and then I compare it to TIHTY and then all of a sudden I have double standards because you added brand new criteria to your original claim?

You try to drag Haus for opinions on Gaga's albums pulling out reviews for Madonna to show she's more acclaimed but then you say Witness is a good album whilst shading Joanne? Either you use critics or you don't. "Jolene" is a far more acclaimed album than Katy's entire career and since reviews and critical acclaim is so important to you, why in the world are you even TRYING this Joanne vs. Witness crap? Katy lost on all accounts.

@mrjacs said: No, Witness is still the mega bomb.

No, that's Bionic.

@LadyFlopgaCocaineQueen said:

@mrjacs said:

You try to drag Haus for opinions on Gaga's albums pulling out reviews for Madonna to show she's more acclaimed but then you say...

No b!tch try again!

You already KNOW the reason I did that is because Cherry was saying Madame X was getting panned by the critics. I even included the quote of Cherry saying it. Cherry was lying and now you are by making up false reasons why I did that. Stop twisting sh!t....Fvck off.

I literally haven't even been on here in months let alone acknowledged that Madonna album. Try harder.

@LadyFlopgaCocaineQueen said:

No b!tch try again!

You already KNOW the reason I did that is because Cherry was saying Madame X was getting panned by the critics. I even included the quote of Cherry saying it. Cherry was lying and now you are by making up false reasons why I did that. Stop twisting sh!t....Fvck off.

You're such a MESS. This is not only about his thread but about you bringing up reviews sooooo often in terms of Gaga's albums in comparison to others but then you say Witness - a critically trashed album - by a critically trashed FLOP HAS BEEN is a good album. YOU have double standards, YOUR problem is you constantly change opinions just to make Gaga look bad. You are everything you say others are and then some. The way you constantly project is hilarious. And sad.