讨论 I Am Groot Collection
讨论 → 电影 → I Am Groot Collection → 内容出错
Reported Problem for I Am Groot Collection
Homer Jr.STAFFMOD 发布于 2022 年 08 月 10 日 6:32下午
Item: I Am Groot Collection
Language: en-US
Type of Problem: Incorrect_content
Extra Details: Hi,
This is a TV series and not a collection of short movies.
-H
superboy97 的回复
于 2022 年 08 月 11 日 12:40上午
No. They are listed as separate movie pages on the Disney+ official site.
atokyo 的回复
于 2022 年 08 月 11 日 1:44上午
I agree with Homer Jr - they are clearly part of a series, and each one is listed as an episode on various other databases. The movies should be deleted and the tv series entry should be reinstated. They are 6 minutes long - clearly not movies, nor intended to be movies. They are listed here on DisneyPlus as a show (not a movie): https://disneyplusoriginals.disney.com/show/i-am-groot
superboy97 的回复
于 2022 年 08 月 11 日 1:47上午
This is just a promotional page.
The official pages on Disney+ are the one indicated above (and other similar page for 4 other short movies).
jedi.jesse 的回复
于 2022 年 08 月 11 日 1:52上午
You can't really disagree... it's a fact that they're separate listings on Disney+. It does seem like a TV show, but they don't talk about it that way:
There's a weird mixture of referring to them as "original shorts" but some things calling them "episodes"...
It looks like Disney is actually very intentionally not calling it a TV Series, but is using their existing framework which calls things episodes.
You have to admit that five 6-minute videos doesn't sound like a TV series either.
atokyo 的回复
于 2022 年 08 月 11 日 1:53上午
To my mind it still makes no sense to list these shorts as individual movies when they really would fit far more naturally into tv shows... the same as every other database or resource lists them. I think that it would be much better to follow what seems to be the obvious classification:
IMDB: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt13623148/ Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_Am_Groot TVmaze: https://www.tvmaze.com/shows/52351/i-am-groot The TVDB: https://thetvdb.com/series/i-am-groot
atokyo 的回复
于 2022 年 08 月 11 日 1:55上午
But do agree that Disney's wordplay doesn't exactly help.
superboy97 的回复
于 2022 年 08 月 11 日 1:55上午
Each site have its own set of rules. Here, we list things as they are officially listed by the original broadcaster. And the broadcaster list them as individual shorts.
atokyo 的回复
于 2022 年 08 月 11 日 2:00上午
I think that given the ambiguity that this still doesn't make sense listing them as movies... when they clearly are not. Marvel and Disney talk about them as a series, and as a show, and so arguments about them being a movie are simply casuistry to my mind. So the TV series has been deleted and that's that is it?
superboy97 的回复
于 2022 年 08 月 11 日 2:02上午
They are officially listed as short movies on the official broadcaster page without ambiguities. So, they should be listed as shorts. "movies" clearly appear in the URL.
atokyo 的回复
于 2022 年 08 月 11 日 2:06上午
Ok...pointless arguing further, but I can see now why many people get frustrated with TMDB for decisions like this that fly in the face of common sense.
superboy97 的回复
于 2022 年 08 月 11 日 2:07上午
This is not a TMDB decision, but a broadcaster decision. We have to follow him.
atokyo 的回复
于 2022 年 08 月 11 日 2:17上午
interestingly, "I am Groot" is listed as an original SERIES on the official Disney channel: https://disneyplusoriginals.disney.com/all-disney+-original-series. But the episodes are NOT listed on the Disney Original Movies listings: https://disneyplusoriginals.disney.com/all-disney+-original-movies.
As I said, I think there is ambiguity, and so respectfully I still don't agree that they should be listed as separate movies, when it seems that Disney views them as an Original Series, and it simply makes far more sense to consider them that way.
superboy97 的回复
于 2022 年 08 月 11 日 2:24上午
The official page is the page where you can view the movies/series, not previous promotional page. Consequently, the official page is here for the first one (and tere are four others).
atokyo 的回复
于 2022 年 08 月 12 日 1:37上午
I still don't agree. I also note that the TV Series is actually called "I am Groot" - the title that has been promoted absolutely everywhere, the title which is listed under its Original TV Series banner, and on which page it specifically refers to each episode as exactly that... and episode... like in a TV show. I am sorry, but I think that the mods have got this wrong.
superboy97 的回复
于 2022 年 08 月 12 日 1:48上午
Did you click on the "I am Groot" link on this page ? If you do it, you will land here and you will read "“I Am Groot” is a collection of five original shorts starring Baby Groot, everyone’s favorite little tree, and features several new and unusual characters. ". This is exactly the way we list it here.