Jennifer Still, an aspiring poet, met a tragic end in Pennsylvania, murdered under mysterious circumstances. The initial investigation focused on her boyfriend and her involvement in "Dungeons & Dragons," a lead that ultimately went nowhere.

Michael Rainsford, a popular 20-year-old skateboarder, was fatally shot through his kitchen window while preparing to visit his girlfriend. The culprits were two brothers, Michael and James Foy, who sought revenge following an unrelated incident.

In 1973, Noreen Kumeta Rudd's life was cut tragically short, just 27 days after marrying Donnie Rudd. Initially deemed a car accident, this event led to Donnie collecting a $120,000 life insurance payout.

In 1998, the murder of Sondra Better in West Palm Beach, Florida, cast a long shadow of mystery, remaining unsolved for two decades. The case experienced a dramatic turn in 2018 when Todd Barket, unsuspectingly, applied for a job.

The murder of Afrikka Hardy in October 2014 was a chilling catalyst for the investigation that ultimately exposed the heinous crimes committed by Darren Deon Vann. Afrikka, a 19-year-old woman, fell victim to Vann's predatory tactics.

Before her tragic murder on August 26, 2011, Amanda Plasse lived as a vibrant young woman. The murder itself was a horrific and violent event, marked by a gruesome crime scene. However, what followed added more pain to her family's grief.

In this tragic case, Tiara Pool, a 21-year-old Navy wife from Jacksonville, Florida, met David Sparre on Craigslist. Their encounter took a horrific turn when Sparre brutally stabbed Tiara 89 times in her apartment in July 2010.

Heather Strube's life took a tragic turn during a bitter custody battle with her ex-husband, Steven Strube. In April 2009, as she went to a Target parking lot for a custody exchange of their son, Carson, she was brutally shot in front of Carson.

Sydney Loofe's vibrant life took a tragic turn in November 2017 when she entered the world of online dating and unknowingly crossed paths with Bailey Boswell and Aubrey Trail. As their second date approached, the couple hatched a sinister plan.

Denita Smith, a 25-year-old graduate student in North Carolina, was murdered on January 4, 2007. Before her tragic death, Shannon Crawley, who had a complicated history with Denita's fiancé, Jermeir Stroud, became extremely jealous.

The murder of Cari Farver unfolded amidst a complex web of jealousy and obsession in her relationships with David Kroupa and Shanna "Liz" Golyar. Cari mysteriously vanished after leaving David's apartment, triggering suspicious text messages.

The tragic case of Gretchen Anthony, a woman known for her vibrant and positive personality, unfolded as a chilling tale of domestic violence and deceit. In March 2020, her estranged husband, David Anthony, murdered her in their Florida home.

Childhood friends Sarah Stern and Liam McAtasney's friendship took a dark turn in December 2016 when Sarah went missing, her car abandoned on a bridge.

In 2010, on Thanksgiving in Ruskin, Florida, former ice cream truck driver Michael Keetley was involved in a tragic shooting that resulted in the deaths of two brothers, Juan and Sergio Guitron, and injured four others.