The team hunts down an old acquaintance from Jeff's days at the Colorado buffalo ranch, who relays a secret about the animal mutilations; the cowboys expose a truth that changes their outlook on where the mutilations are coming from.

Jeff believes there is extraterrestrial activity within the Southern Arizona ranches he and the team are investigating; a little girl goes missing near a cornfield and the Cowboy Skywatchers must team up with local law enforcement.

The cowboys track down a local rancher who's had a recent experience with mysterious lights in the sky; the team races to the site of a UFO encounter that is underway at a live event.

After a pursuit of the lights in the sky, the Cowboy Skywatchers discover that a local police officer has evidence of recent UFO encounters that are similar to what the team has experienced.

After proving the existence of the creature in the cornfield, the unusual activity in Southern Arizona increases; the Cowboy Skywatchers split up their team, as they find themselves in a hunt back into the cornfield.