A woman of faith, Susan Hernandez, is the last person police would expect to find murdered in her basement; searching for suspects, detectives turn over every stone in the hunt for Susan’s killer, with a result that shakes the town to its core.

In Alabama, Brucetravius Frazier lies dead in his car from a gunshot wound to his head. A subsequent attempt on a witness's life causes police to realize they're not dealing with the average killer and must work quickly to bring them to justice.

Samantha Guthrie's parents desperately search for their missing child. As the police search reveals many players in this mystery, there is one common thread - the Lillian St. house. Police aim to find the truth of what occurred within those walls.

In Akron, OH, local antiques dealer Mary Kay Wohlfarth mysteriously vanishes into thin air; detectives race to find the elderly woman, leaving no stone unturned; however, finding Mary Kay might lead to more questions than answers.

Detectives in Waynesfield, OH, contend with a grim mystery when they discover the lifeless body of Erin Mulcahy in her shower. The pressure is now on the police department to catch those responsible for the town's first murder in over fifty years.

Forty-year-old Jamie Baker leaves behind her family when someone shoots and kills her with a bullet through the back. The mystery only deepens when police dig into her last moments and uncover what transpired the night of her death.

When workers find a decomposed body on an abandoned property in western Ohio, Paulding County Sheriff’s Office deputies race to the scene. The findings of the homicide investigation that follows send shockwaves throughout the Amish community.

The town of Fort Smith, AR, reels when an elderly, retired school teacher turns up dead, bludgeoned to death with a hammer no fewer than 36 times. When the person responsible receives justice, an unlikely perpetrator comes to light.

Local police confront their worst fears when the body of a local EMT is found at her home in Columbus, GA. The ensuing investigation shocks the wider community and tests the public's faith in law enforcement itself.