We reunite with the Ghostfacers after their footage had been destroyed by Supernatural stars, Sam and Dean. Because Corbett died on their last mission, they had to hire a new intern. First there was Dave, but he got fired after the hot girl Ambyr walked in and asked for the job. Maggie found a potential job for them at the Grand Showcase Theatre, because she thought it might be haunted by Janet Myers, who had been killed by her ex-husband.

The Ghostfacers prepare for their first mission at the grand showcase theater. Ambyr isn't really being of much help as an intern, but her good looks apparently make up for that. Maggie and Harry tell everyone about the romance that went down between them on their last mission.

The Ghostfacers have arrived at the Grand Showcase Theatre and they decide to split up. Harry and Ed play rock, paper, scissors and whoever wins gets to go out exploring with Ambyr. Ed wins and tells us about Ambyr who apparently has 'it', also explained as the shining. Maggie, Spruce and Harry run into their first ghost.

The Ghostfacers have found the screen test of Janet Myers, the woman who's been hunting the theatre, and think she might still be hanging around the theatre because she's waiting for her big break. Meanwhile Maggie is looking into the footage and finds out that Janet is visible in the reflection of the mirror, but when you turn around you can't see her anymore. Ed concludes that they need loads of mirrors in order for them to face her.

The Ghostfacers have been spread out across the Theatre standing in front of mirrors to catch a glimpse of the ghost of Janet Myers. While waiting Harry is trying to set the mood with Maggie, but she confronts him about Ambyr and how he's been drowling all over her. Meanwhile, Ed is waiting by the monitors, losing visual contact with all the Ghostfacers one by one.

After Ed had been attacked by the ghost of Janet Myers he decides he wants to stay in the theatre and find a way to get rid of the ghost, eventhough they already caught her on camera and the other Ghostfacers wanted to leave. After some persuading Ed gets them to stay and they come up with the idea that the spirit of the ghost might be attached to the screen test.

Spruce performs a ritual that is supposed to destroy the ghost of Janet Myers and after this went down the Ghostfacers think the ghost is gone. Maggie and Harry have a romantic moment, but it gets once again ruined by Spruce. Ambyr is sort of flirting with Ed, while he is watching her on the monitor. This is when she gets face to face with the ghost, who apparently wasn't dead afterall.

Ambyr gets attacked by the ghost of Janet Myers and Ed tries to fight the ghost in order to save Ambyr. He soon realises that the ghost can only be here because of the mirrors, so the team slashes all the mirrors in the theatre and the ghost disappears after the last mirror was broked by Ed.

We jump six weeks in time and we find that all the members have moved on from the Ghostfacers: Maggie is getting her masters, Spruce is busy LARPing and Ed works at a Pizza Place. But then Harry sees this article in the newspaper saying the Grand Showcase Theatre had been sold and if they hadn't killed the ghost a lot of people would have died. This is a good reason for Ed to rejoin the Ghostfacers and him and Harry are off to find the supernatural again.