At the annual Witch Day Festival, Kimberly mixes up a magic witch potion that actually works, causing Jing to become possessed. Duncan and his friends enter a haunted Circuit City and Jack tries again to finally win Annie a stuffed animal at the milk bottle toss.

When Yangzi becomes addicted to his new phone, his friends stage an intervention to break him of his habit so he can experience the real world again. Meanwhile, Kimberly starts babysitting for Bradley but uncovers his mother's therapy files with secrets about many of the town's residents.