Bloomington, IL, Sergeant Jeff Pelo is a respected police officer and, at home, he's a model father and husband. When he's caught trespassing after midnight on a young woman's property, his spotless reputation comes under fire.

When dozens of women vanish from the Sunshine State in the late '60s, the get filed as presumed runways; police discover the bodies of two missing teens, uncovering the sadistic work of a prolific serial killer.

Mike Dixiano is heartbroken when his wife, Angela, dies from organ failure after a lifelong battle with drugs and alcohol. While friends and family grieve Angela's death, investigators can't find a death certificate and begin to suspect her husband.

Wife and mother Stephanie Roller Bruner vanishes in a blizzard shortly before Thanksgiving, prompting officers to launch a massive search. Then, the sordid details of a secret love triangle emerge, causing the case to take a twisted turn.