The murders of two young boys puts a tragic end to their short lives, but kickstarts a lasting friendship between their mothers. When the case goes cold, the women begin their own quest for answers.

The 1999 murder of a 17-year-old sends shockwaves across a rural Kentucky community. When the police investigation stalls, her family vows to solve it themselves. But in their long hunt for justice, they discover that evil is sickeningly close to home.