Coop and Cami are preparing for the school dance when they learn their mother is ready to start to dating again, now that it's been two years since their father passed away. Much to their dismay, the date is their school principal.

Cooper is upset to learn that Peyton is moving to Canada and doesn’t seem sad to be leaving.

When a new online show, run by a person in a bunny costume, "Which Would You Prefer" threatens Would You Wrather, Coop, Cami, and Fred set out to find who is behind the mask. Meanwhile, Charlotte gets Jenna on social media.

Cami discovers that Tara is planning to replace Delaware on the NPC Dance Team, and struggles when she realizes that it may inadvertently be her fault.

Cami struggles when she inadvertently reveals secrets that Cooper and Peyton didn't want the other to know.

When Coop and Fred mistakenly take the juice bar barista Jen for Ariana Grande, they invite her to Cami's 13th birthday party, and she then tells everyone how excited she is to have her favorite singer at her party.

Cooper arranges for the Glamtronics to perform at the annual Firefighters' Ball, but it winds up being the same night of Peyton's going away party.