In September 2012, University of Florida freshman Christian Aguilar mysteriously vanishes from campus. His girlfriend, father and best friend are in turmoil. Police have nowhere to turn -- until a CCTV recording turns the case in a shocking new direction.

19-year-old college student Katie Poirier vanishes while working the graveyard shift at a gas station. It’s a family’s worst nightmare come true. Grainy security footage reveals an answer but leaves a community in fear.