Maria’s birthday. Blindfolded before a swinging piñata, she hits it and tears it open. Odd, unsmiling children swarm around the candy. Suddenly, Maria is swept into the arms of her father, who whispers in her ear: “You’ll always be my baby girl, no matter what.” It isn’t sweet.

In order to rescue Grace, Maria must trespass into Purgatory and face a ghost from her own past; and Enos' dark forces draw closer. Meanwhile, David confronts a terrible secret.

A demonic lover makes Abigail an indecent proposal as Maria and Dusty grow closer; and the Reverend forbids his daughter from seeing David. Meanwhile, Grace searches for the truth about her mother.