Josh wants to hire computer genius Cooper Finley (guest star Jesse McCartney), but an awkward incident with Gabi leads Josh to punching Cooper rather than hiring him. Now Gabi is determined to make things right between them, leading to a different kind of spark between her and Cooper. Meanwhile, Elliot and Yolanda each scheme to be the first person to try out the fancy new bathtub Josh had installed.

Gabi is excited by an upcoming visit from Cooper, especially since they’re about to take their relationship to the next level. But then Cooper accidentally finds out more than he should about the last person Gabi was with. Meanwhile, Josh is furious to find out that Yolanda is spending time with her ex-husband, Coleman.

Gabi has returned from her internship in Switzerland and is anxious to face Josh after how things were left between them. But Josh insists he’s fine and encourages Gabi to take a job with his new neighbor. But when Josh thinks his neighbor might have a thing for Gabi, he takes to spying to learn the truth.

Josh and Gabi’s night is ruined when Gabi’s dad, Nick, surprises her with a visit. Determined to make a good impression, Josh embellishes his relationship with his own mom, Kathy, and sets up a dinner for the four of them.

Josh shows up in Hawaii to find out what Gabi is doing with her fake husband Adam. But Gabi is desperate to escape back to San Francisco, only to have a hurricane trap everyone on the island. Meanwhile, Elliot is angry after he is saved from a life-threatening situation by Yolanda rather than his husband Alan.

Gabi takes Sofia on a last-minute vacation to Mexico to cover up the fact that she forgot her birthday; while taking care of Josh after surgery, Elliot and Yolanda accidentally ruin his new multimillion-dollar purchase.