Carly and Spencer become upset when their new neighbor Griffin steals Spencer's motorcycle. Spencer lets Griffin off the hook, making Carly upset. However, when Spencer later goes out to get smoothies, he returns to find Carly and Griffin kissing on the couch. Spencer becomes furious and forbids Carly to see him. Meanwhile, Sam pays Freddie $50 to make a website.

With Spencer's blessing, Carly and Griffin's relationship advances happily and without flaw, until Griffin reveals that he obsessively and neurotically collects a series of stuffed animals called "Pee Wee Babies".

Spencer comes to the rescue when a heat wave hits Seattle and the power goes out.