Carly, Sam and Freddie want their show to be reviewed. Carly risks receiving a bad review when she insults the annoying eleven year old who runs a popular site that rates web casts.

The Plain White T's are set to perform on iCarly, but Nevel plans to ruin the event by hacking into the site.

In an attempt to spice up the Christmas tradition with an unconventional tree, Spencer accidentally sets fire to all of Carly's presents. Carly makes a wish that Spencer was born normal.

iCarly holds a giveaway contest for a new car -- won by their nemesis, Nevel Papperman. Meanwhile, Spencer buys a Galaxy Wars prop online.

Spencer gets a new credit card after canceling his old one, causing Carly, Sam, and Freddie to lose control of the iCarly.com domain. Luckily, Mandy (who appeared in "iAm Your Biggest Fan") returns to buy their website back for them, but she gets tricked into giving it to Nevel. Spencer disguises as an old woman to trick Nevel into signing the URL transfer document during a book signing, but is chased out by security after Nevel recognized him. Later, Nevel demands a kiss from Carly in return to claim the transfer document. Carly confronts Nevel, and Nevel signs the document. However Carly escapes with the signed document without having to kiss Nevel and succeeds in reclaiming their website.

When Carly jokingly challenges MMA fighter Shelby Marx to fight, the two agree to have an exhibition fight for charity. Unfortunately, Carly accidentally falls on Shelby's grandmother during a press conference. Thinking Shelby wants revenge, Carly backs out of the fight, only to be ridiculed as a coward.

Carly visits Shelby and apologizes, and the fight is back on. However, when Nevel Papperman alters a clip of the press conference to make it look like Carly intentionally tackled Shelby's grandma, Shelby becomes furious and genuinely attacks Carly during their boxing match.

Nevel's image is ruined after a video of him berating a child goes viral, so he asks Carly and the gang for help in restoring his reputation.

Carly, Sam, and Freddie wonder why people can't celebrate Halloween more than once a year. They decide to celebrate it halfway through the year as well creating a new holiday termed "Halfoween" and have a party.