Baby Heart Throb, Baby Lofty and Baby Half Note want to sing backup for Knight Shade. But to their dismay, he has stolen their shadows, which contain all of their energy and substance. The Ponies soon discover that the evil wizard Arabus is behind Knight Shade's behavior, and now it's up to the Flutter Ponies to save the day.

Baby Heart Throb, Baby Lofty and Baby Half Note want to sing backup for Knight Shade. But to their dismay, he has stolen their shadows, which contain all of their energy and substance. The Ponies soon discover that the evil wizard Arabus is behind Knight Shade's behavior, and now it's up to the Flutter Ponies to save the day.

Megan and Molly take Baby Heart Throb, Baby Lofty and Baby Half Note to a concert featuring their favorite singer, Night Shade and his back up singers, the Shadowets. After the concert is over, Baby Heart Throb and the other baby ponies meet Night Shade and get their shadows stolen, which leaves them feeling sick and very dizzy. They are soon trapped in a cage by three giant rats and must wait in fear for Megan and their mothers to save them.

Zeb and Erebus nearly steal everyone's shadow before Molly's ride for help is a success.

The First Tooth Baby Ponies are put in charge of the Newborn Twines: Sniffles & Snookums and Milkweed & Tumbleweed. The unruly twins are temporarily subdued with the promise of ice cream, but the First Tooth Baby Ponies must first reunite feuding ice cream makers Rocky Ripple and Fudgy McSwain, who have cut off Ponyland's ice cream supply.