Young jock Jack and nerdy twink Eric are horny for each other’s stepdad, so they steal used underwear from them to trade and sniff while jerking off. The problem is that they are not cautious enough, and their stepdads Johnny and Muscled Madison overhear them from the next room, coming up to see what the fuss is about. When they discover what’s going on, instead of scolding them, they decide to fulfill the boys’ fantasy!

While running around the house, Eric and Jack break a lamp. Madison and his friend Johnny are in the other room when they hear the mess their stepsons made, so they come to see what the fuss is about. When they discover the broken lamp, Madison shows Johnny how he deals with these kinds of situations. It seems that making Jack suck his stepdad’s cock teaches the boy how to behave. Impressed, Johnny tries the same method with his stepson Eric. The lesson turns into a hot foursome as Johnny and Madison explore unorthodox “parenting methods” with their stepsons.

In the quiet anticipation of their first big plane trip to California, Eric and Ryan found themselves sharing a bed. The unfamiliar closeness and excitement of the impending adventure with their stepdads, Ryan and Brody, created an atmosphere of nervous energy. However, Ryan's restless habit of stroking his cock was proving to be a major obstacle to a good night's sleep for Eric. The sound and movements emanating from Ryan's side of the bed filled the room, keeping Eric on edge and wide awake. Eric’s frustration grew with each passing minute, until their stepdads, Ryan and Brody, came into the room. Concerned that the lack of sleep would negatively impact the boys' experience on the trip, the stepdads knew they had to intervene. Confident that a good ass-pounding would curb their excitement, the hung stepdaddies show their stepsons how dick can solve any situation, packing meat into the young men’s butts ‘til they are finally ready for sleep.

Oops! Eric and his buddy Ryan were playing some ball in the backyard when they accidentally broke the basement window. Hoping not to get caught, they tried to hide the evidence and pretend to be studying in the living room when the accident happened, but Ryan and Brody, their loving stepdad, quickly called their bullshit. Now cornered by their stepdads, Ryan and Eric try to blame each other, but Brody and Ryan don’t want to be lied to anymore. They know they need to teach their boys a lesson about honesty and respect and the only way to do it is with good old-fashioned discipline. Pulling their cocks out, the stepfathers make the young men eat their dicks, but to avoid things getting awkward, they swap stepsons. The punishment soon evolves into a nice foursome, and the boys eventually learn their lesson: it’s best not to lie to your stepdad…unless you want his dick!