The Darrow sisters and Nina's boyfriend, Frank, go to the city in Addie's search for answers about Maggie's disappearance. While at the University library, Addie discovers some devastating information about Maggie's sister, Elinor.

Despite Mr. MacIntosh's strict rules about using the town hall and Miss Murphy's attempts to shut it down, Addie’s birthday party for Nina and Keedie is a success. But when Addie's bully Emily crashes the party, things take a downward turn.

Backstage drama threatens the school's production of Macbeth. Emily's jealousy reaches a breaking point and she lashes out at Addie. Nina and Keedie must then rescue their little sister from the wrath of Miss Murphy.

Audrey schedules a day off for Addie, hoping to find time to tell her about New York. Keedie and Nina watch the shop in Addie's absence and find evidence that someone has been breaking in. Jenna attempts to catch Jude's eye. Emily rights a wrong.

With the Founders’ Day dance approaching, Addie must find a story from Juniper’s past that the town can all be proud of. Bonnie lets Addie know that she has a story that fits the bill. Nina struggles with her options for college.