Gina confides in Paul and Lily about hiding out from her ex-husband Randy, who has surprisingly showed up in Bridgewater. Paul's father also has a heart attack and Paul is debating if he should go visit him.

A tornado puts Tommy's life in danger and threatens to expose the Rader family's secret.

Paul's efforts to get Cunningham to reveal what he knows about Erin's murder spawns a surprising confession that leaves the Rader family facing the most difficult decision of their lives.