Family man and teacher Dusty Hubbard begins to reevaluate his life and happiness after the arrival of a strange machine called the Morpho.

Dusty and Cass host a dinner as she wrestles with what her Morpho card might mean. Deerfield’s citizens start making drastic life changes.

As the town prepares for Deerfield High's homecoming basketball game, Jacob is encouraged to step into his brother's shoes.

Cass and Dusty deal with the fallout from the magic show. Trina comes clean about Jacob. An approaching storm threatens Deerfield.

Father Reuben makes a discovery about Hana. Dusty and Cass contemplate their future. The Morpho reveals a new mystery.

Dusty and Cass make a big decision about their relationship. Trina and Jacob throw a house party.

Dusty and the boys host a school event at Giorgio's restaurant. Cass, Nat, and Hana have a girls' night out.

On her first date with Freya, Izzy has an awkward run-in with Cass. Dusty volunteers to direct the school play.

Deerfield High adds a twist to its production of Our Town. Giorgio helps Father Reuben with Hana. Dusty and Cass second-guess their separation.