Paul and Alva investigate a young Amish girl who shows signs of stigmata, and discover that she is being taken over by another personality. Her family believes the devil has a hold on her, but Alva suspects she may be channeling the spirit of a young suicide victim.

Paul and the gang investigate a haunted real estate office. Everyone who works there is convinced that there is a ghost, all except Larry Kittredge, the owner. Paul and the others discover that Larry believes the ghost is his dead son who has come back to him. As the hauntings worsen, SQ must convince him that it is he, not his son, who is responsible.

As Paul begins seeing the ghost of Tommy around, SQ investigates a TV psychic. They soon discover he's fake, but the psychic then has a real vision/revelation regarding Paul. Later, after Matty disappears, Paul decides to contact Tommy to find out what he wants and how to help Matty. But the only way to that is...to die.