Jon goes out on a date with Liz to Vito's Pizzaria and Garfield wants to go along, but Vito banned animals from entering the restaurant. So Garfield and Odie disguise themselves as Jon's "daughters" to get into Vito's, but Jon and Liz's date turns into disaster.

After Garfield plays a mean trick on Nermal, a bowling ball falls on his head and loses his memory. Then, Nermal tricks Garfield into thinking he's a stray cat named Ichabod. Then Garfield meets a couple of stray cats named Tino and Gino. This is Tino and Gino's first appearance.

Vito is sad after Angeluca broke up with him.