For the first time in Zoey 101, Zoey Brooks struggles with a class, Chemistry, where she scores a "C" on a test. She is given a new tutor; to her surprise, her tutor is Logan who happens to be one of the best pupils. Zoey starts learning Chemistry with Logan behind her friends' backs. All of her friends become suspicious, especially Chase. Chase tries to find out why, so Logan lies and says that Zoey is going out with him.

After developing a crush on Lisa (Lisa Tucker), Michael becomes too nervous to perform in the Open Mic night, causing him to throw up on her and making Lisa like another guy. Can Michael still get the girl of his dreams? Meanwhile, Logan and Chase are having a go-kart race.