Sue helps look for Katie who was kidnapped from Gallaudet University. Sue & Jack question Lance who says he didn't kidnap Katie. Sue & Jack don't believe the story. Sue learns that Katie was adopted and found her biological mom after 19 years.

Sue and Jack go undercover at law firm to find out why a lawyer and judge were murdered that the only connection the team has to go on is that the judge and lawyer worked for the same law firm. Myles mentions another connection his sister Ann also works at the same law firm.

Myles takes the opportunity to reconnect with his sister while trying to uncover who was behind the murders. Ann tells Jack and Myles that Hillary was using a computer program where dates and other things were tracked.

Jack learns that Brian Peyton was the hit man behind the murder of James Radley.

Jack runs into a bounty hunter named Joe who used to work at the FBI until his daughter died. He blames Jack for his daughter's problems. Although the team searches for Fantasia (a new designer drug) Levi learns that he will grace the box of the latest dog food only to learn that it isn't so easy to do.

Sue and Lucy begin the have problems with the photographer that has chosen to photograph Levi. Sue and Lucy learn that Levi will have to compete with the photographer's dog in order to be included in the latest dog calendar.