Cosmo and Wanda must go to the Fairy Academy to have their Godparenting License renewed, and their drill instructor is the toughest fairy in the universe, Jorgen Von Strangle. While they are absent, Timmy gets a substitute godparent, Jeff, who can only make toys; it turns out that Jeff is a runaway elf from the North Pole.

Timmy, Cosmo, and Wanda are nominated for a Fairy World award show, but Jorgen Von Strangle, the toughest fairy in the universe, uses his power to "persuade" the judges; in a subplot, Timmy's left buck tooth is loose.

Cosmo and Wanda try to help Timmy capture Bigfoot to earn his Squirrel Scout badge in capturing a mythical creature.

Timmy wishes to be a superhero like the Crimson Chin, and tries out various powers, ultimately getting into battle with a three-headed monster. At the end, however, he wished for "super-vision" and he ended up back home with his parents ("supervision").

According to "Da Rules" once every few thousand years a fairy must act bad for a day and it's Cosmo's turn.