The whole town attends the annual Scarecrow Festival, where cousins Kelly and Shrub compete.

Kelly and Shrub attempt to do good deeds in town, hoping to get a reward.

As Shrub thrives at his new job and Kelly gets a starring role in the car lot’s commercial, Father Joe begins to miss having them around.

Kelly's father puts her in charge of the Flatch Christmas celebration, and disaster ensues involving a holiday gift exchange, a fire and Shrub breaking some news to Kelly.

Mandy, Barb and Dylan are throwing their hats in the ring for the town 'selectperson,' and everyone is taking sides for their heated town debate. Kelly and Nadine may finally have to bury the hatchet when they need each other most. When a tornado makes its way through the town, Flatch spins out of control.