On the boat,Tamira confides in Sean that she must leave Breaker High due to financial reasons. Feeling he must help, he throws a Brady Bunch Night to raise money for Tamira. Unfortunately that theme night fails, but Sean is more successful when he throws a Gilligan's Island Night. After the party Sean gives Tamira the money raised and she's able to stay at the school with no one the wiser and her dignity intact.

In Norway, Jimmy eavesdrops on Cassidy and Denise and mistakenly believes that Denise is crushing on Sean. Ashley's hometown boyfriend, Tyler shows up which infuriates Alex when he becomes her second man.

In New York, the students reminisce of their first days on Breaker High when they are quarantined due to a supposed Hepatitis A outbreak.

On the boat, Tamira reveals that she kissed Max and sets off a chain reaction amongst the couples of the ship in the midst of Denise's Carnival for the Costa Rican Kids. Meanwhile, Jimmy tries to amuse the kids but just can't seem to do it. In the end, the couples make up, except for Tamira and Sean.