Sprijin Bază de date filme (The Movie Database)

Hello,

I don’t know for certain where I should post this but there is currently no page for Paul Schrader‘s “Dark” which makes no sense why not which was his own personal re-edit of the original titled film “Dying of the Light” which is a version he doesn’t support. A page really should be made of “Dark” on here. I don’t know I need to do it or someone from the site needs to in order to connect it with Letterboxd’s page so content like posters & such can be uploaded.

5 răspunsuri (pe pagina 1 din 1)

Jump to last post

I invite you to read this old content report.

I read the content report but I don’t agree with the assessment. I understand in not wanting unofficial versions but the film was re-edited by the Director Paul Schrader, himself and the film can be watched on YouTube as the film is run through UCLA’s Film Archives. It would be one thing if some random person did the edit but it’s the Director and obviously, it’s an official version if it’s being distributed for streaming through an established channel that doesn’t just collect content from anyone. I think there should be some reconsideration on the matter.

The main cause of the removal was that it's an alternate version.

The second line is just a complement, this is not the reason of the removal.

Hmm…I don’t necessarily agree with this. You have alternative versions already on here. Look no further than “Justice League” & “Zack Snyder’s Justice League”. Snyder’s version is an alternative which by that standard shouldn’t be on here then. It’s the same with Schrader’s situation but different. The original version was stripped from Schrader during post-production in his case. One could argue that “Dark” is just as much an original film as the producer’s version “Dying of the Light”. They have different titles & could be potentially claimed as 2 different films really unlike the Justice League situation. This is not a typical Director’s Cut scenario which is usually just an alternative version of the same exact title but yet, you’ve already broken the whole “don’t accept” alternative versions with “Justice League”. It seems a bit double standard if you ask me.

@TheCinephileKing said:

Look no further than “Justice League” & “Zack Snyder’s Justice League”.

There are very few of them. They are exceptions that have been approved by the administrator at the time of the broadcast.

Nu găsiți un film sau un serial? Autentificați-vă pentru a-l crea.

Globale

s focalizează bara de căutare
p deschide meniul profilului
esc închide o fereastră deschisă
? deschide fereastra cu scurtături de la tastatură

Pe paginile media

b mergi înapoi (sau la părinte atunci când este cazul)
e mergi la pagina de editare

Pe paginile sezoanelor filmelor seriale

(săgeată dreapta) mergi la sezonul următor
(săgeată stânga) mergi la sezonul precedent

Pe paginile episoadelor filmelor seriale

(săgeată dreapta) mergi la episodul următor
(săgeată stânga) mergi la episodul precedent

Pe toate paginile de imagini

a deschide fereastra pentru adăugarea de imagini

Pe toate paginile de editare

t deschide selectorul de traduceri
ctrl+ s trimite formularul

Pe paginile de discuții

n crează o discuție nouă
w comută starea de vizionare
p comută publică/privată
c comută închisă/deschisă
a deschide activitatea
r răspunde la discuție
l mergi la ultimul răspuns
ctrl+ enter trimite mesajul
(săgeată dreapta) pagina următoare
(săgeată stânga) pagina precedentă

Setări

Doriți să evaluați sau să adăugați acest articol într-o listă?

Autentificare